New religious organizations in Japan today clearly reveal that
Buddhism has retained its influence on modern Japanese society.
Lay Buddhist Movements in Modern Japan
It is widely said that the Japanese people have no religion or that
they have abandoned their religious traditions in the process of
Westernization. Buddhist temples have been accused of having lost their
religious energies and of conducting only funerals and related services
since early modern times. In fact, modern Buddhist movements in Japan
are playing great roles in the political, economic, and social spheres.
This is the result of Buddhist organizations living up to their
philosophies and ways of living, which in turn influences the thoughts
and behavior of the people. Thus, new religious organizations in Japan
today clearly reveal that Buddhism has retained its influence on modern
Japanese society.
These modern religious movements vary in character. The most
influential were established during the early nineteenth century and
have doctrines different from the traditional religious organizations.
They are collectively called New Religions, and can be largely divided
into Buddhist-inspired and Shinto-inspired groups. An overwhelming
majority of Buddhist-oriented New Religions are based on the Lotus
Sutra and Nichiren Buddhism. They include Soka Gakkai, by far the
largest in membership; Rissho Kosei-kai, the second largest in
membership, emphasizing a peace movement and interreligious
cooperation; Reiyukai, which has given rise to other religious
organizations of laypersons; Myochikai, under the Reiyukai umbrella,
which places an emphasis on social activities; Honmon Butsuryuko, the
first of the Buddhist-oriented New Religions; Hoonji Temple, successor
to Bukkyo Kanka Kyusaikai, which was considered a remarkable case of
socially engaged Buddhism; and Nihon-zan Myohoji Temple, which has
striven to propagate its doctrine overseas and to promote its peace
movement. In parallel to these New Religions, there have been
Kokuchukai, established by Chigaku Tanaka; Toitsukaku, by Nissho Honda;
and others as influential movements targeted at Buddhist monks and
intellectuals.1
Although these religious organizations and movements have carried on
much of the Lotus Sutra tradition of Nichiren Buddhism, the ways they
have succeeded and developed vary. Considering that so many religious
organizations that are based on Lotus Sutra/Nichiren Buddhism have
developed in modern Japan, a need naturally emerges to identify the
points that many of those religions have in common, to examine the
characteristics of them, and to explain the reason for their
development.
It is useful to note the ideological characteristics that many New
Religions have in common with the ideological characteristics of the
traditions of the Lotus Sutra and the Nichiren sects that they have
succeeded. Three elements appear to be important, namely, a concept of
integration through horizontal solidarity, an emphasis on helping
people to become self-reliant, and a this-world orientation.
Features of Lotus Sutra/Nichiren-School Buddhism Adapted to Modern Society
Integration through Horizontal Solidarity
At present, the people's sense of solidarity has been lost, and there
are divisions and conflicts within and among classes, nations, and
religions that we should attempt to overcome through solidarity on the
horizontal level instead of through hierarchic relations. In general,
religions seeking salvation have an inclination toward integration
through horizontal solidarity.2
Two important characteristics of salvation religions are that they
awaken in individuals an awareness of their identity and promote
integration through horizontal solidarity. Such a concept is needed in
an age when new political and social orders are being formed. In modern
times, capitalism spread globally with Western colonialism, and the
concept of the nation-state divided the world. It was an age when a
concept of horizontal integration was sought in lieu of the
conventional idea of hierarchical integration. In other words,
individuals, faced with new types of differences and diversity, began
to seek a vision of horizontal integration anew.
The Lotus Sutra arose from the Mahayana movement, which taught a
belief in bodhisattvas in an effort to narrow the gap between monks and
lay followers. Comparing bodhisattvas with the Hinayana ascetics called
sravakas and pratyekabuddhas, distinguishing among the
three vehicles (the Bodhisattva Vehicle, teachings not only for oneself
but to lead others to the level of enlightenment; the Sravaka Vehicle, teachings transmitted directly from Shakyamuni Buddha with the aim of attaining enlightenment for oneself; and the Pratyekabuddha
Vehicle, teachings to attain enlightenment by oneself that are not
directly transmitted by the Buddha), and noting the diversity of the
many sutras and doctrines preached by Shakyamuni Buddha, the Lotus
Sutra attempts to integrate them beyond their differences into the One
Vehicle of the Buddha's true teachings, through which all followers can
reach enlightenment.
Along with the development of the Mahayana tradition, doctrines,
sutras, organizations, and relationships with society branched out in
different directions, leading to disunion within the Buddhist
community. While taking into consideration how these differences and
conflicts widened and deepened, the Lotus Sutra evolved a unique
philosophy as to how the integration of Buddhism and society could be
restored. Belief in the One Vehicle of the Lotus Sutra could integrate
the whole Buddhist world and thus build one religious community. This
belief exerted a great influence on the Lotus Sutra Buddhism of
T'ien-t'ai Chih-i in late-sixth-century China as well as on the
traditions of various Buddhist sects originating from the Tendai sect,
which was founded in Japan by Saicho (767-822).
Nichiren (1222-82) saw that unity had been lost and the Buddhist
community was divided into various organizations under various sects.
He attempted to reintegrate the Buddhist organizations under the Lotus
Sutra. In ancient Japan, all Buddhist sects were, in principle,
integrated under the major temples around Nara and Kyoto. However, when
the power of the Heian court collapsed and rival clans of warriors took
control of the land, pessimism resulting from the teaching of the
Latter Day of the Law became prevalent. The Latter Day of the Law
comprises the last of the three periods of Buddhism following
Shakyamuni Buddha's death, when his teachings are believed to fall into
confusion and lose the power to lead people to enlightenment. Buddhist
organizations created by independent recluse monks increased. The
advent of the Jodo (Pure Land) sect by Honen, who attempted to exclude
all practices except for chanting nenbutsu (a prayer to
Amitabha) following armed conflicts in Kyoto, made people think that
Buddhist teachings could not control the chaos in society. There was
also the impending danger of a Mongolian invasion.
Under such circumstances, Nichiren thought that only a belief in the
Lotus Sutra would be able to restore the integration of Buddhist
organizations and rescue the nation from crisis. He also thought that
it would restore the Japanese state in the face of the attempted
invasion by Kublai Khan. It was the desire for horizontal integration
among people who were engaged in bodhisattva practice that would enable
such integration to happen. Nichiren attempted to redirect the strong
orientation toward integration described in the Lotus Sutra into the
reintegration of the state and the Buddhist community in an age of
crisis.
It is easily understood that the tradition of integration based on
the horizontal solidarity of Lotus Sutra/Nichiren Buddhism has inspired
the populace in modern Japan. Indeed, New Religions based on Lotus
Sutra/Nichiren Buddhism have become conspicuous for presenting methods
of integration. The concept of integration through religious solidarity
has at times been in harmony, and at other times in conflict, with that
of national integration, and both concepts, influencing each other,
have contributed to the formation of the concept of spiritual
integration in modern Japan.
The Principle of Self-Reliance
The term principle of self-reliance (jirikishugi),
which was coined by Shigeru Nishiyama in 1990, expresses the
characteristic of the New Religions in the Lotus Sutra/Nichiren
tradition that as practitioners of the bodhisattva way, people should
take part in religious, social, and political activities.
Salvation religions are meant for everyone, and they place stress
upon self-reliance as an important factor in attaining salvation. This
concept was contained to some extent in ancient Buddhism, but it was
the Mahayana concept of the bodhisattva that developed the potential to
its full scale. With bodhisattva practice, the principle of
self-reliance places stress on respecting the positive participation
and practice of laypersons.
The concept of bodhisattva practice occupies the central position in
the Lotus Sutra, which describes ideal followers as those who ardently
accept, read, chant, explain, and transcribe the Lotus Sutra, strongly
advocating that they withstand suffering and help the suffering people
around them to attain salvation. The images of the bodhisattva who
suffers because of his faith (chapter 13 of the Lotus Sutra), the
bodhisattva who tries to find something to respect in each person
(Bodhisattva Never Despise), and a number of bodhisattvas that emerge
from the earth following the teachings of Shakyamuni as the Eternal
Buddha were considered to be ideal models for followers of the Lotus
Sutra.
Nichiren attempted to live up to the ideal image of the bodhisattva
as described in the Lotus Sutra. He believed that he embodied the life
of a bodhisattva, and he persuaded others to follow his way of putting
his belief into practice. He preached right living and righteous faith
and devoted himself to saving the people and the country. In the course
of his activities, he was confronted with many hardships, and he asked
himself why he had to go through such hardships; he finally realized
that it was because he was a bodhisattva with an extremely important
mission. He taught that people should follow the path of a bodhisattva.
Nichiren insisted that by chanting Namu Myoho Renge-kyo (I take
refuge in the Lotus Sutra), people could embody the true character of
the Buddha in themselves and thus be enabled to stand on their own feet
and go forward as Buddhists.
The principle of self-reliance in Lotus Sutra/Nichiren Buddhism
presented a symbolic resource that the leaders and followers of New
Religions in modern Japan could follow. As the process of modernization
advanced, it became increasingly necessary for individuals to become
aware of being bearers of their own destinies, that is, to have
self-identity and responsibility as individuals, and the principle of
self-reliance of Lotus Sutra/Nichiren Buddhism must have been very
encouraging for them. They chose their faith and lifestyles and
intended to overcome hardships themselves. Then they chose to speak
about their experiences with others in order to help them become
self-reliant and to persuade them to explore their lives with a sense
of mission.
This-World Orientation
The opposite of this-world orientation is other-world orientation, or
the denial of this world. In religions, particularly in salvation
religions, the existence of the other world, which is quite different
from this world, is usually assumed. The concept of salvation often
accompanies a vision that one will relate with a divine being in a
realm beyond the limits in this world, especially beyond death. The
realm different from this world, for example, may be the other-world
after death or the state of tranquillity (nirvana) beyond the world of
transmigration. Supposing the existence of the sublime realm, this
world is given a negative value and characterized as being filled with
wrongs and sufferings. In salvation religions in which asceticism in
line with the orientation of denying this world is considered the ideal
for clergy, the salvation concept means emancipation from this world.
However, in Japanese New Religions, there is a strong inclination
toward seeking salvation here within this world. This view of salvation
is characterized as a "vitalistic view of salvation" (Tsushima et al.,
1979). Considering that God, the Buddha, and the universe are the
source of life, people consider themselves to be saved if they can live
a happy life in this world by being united with the Great Source of
Life and blessed with good health. They seldom show any interest in the
other world. They are more concerned about their individual and group
life in this world and are actively involved in improving their lives.
In the explanation of integration based on horizontal solidarity, a
reference was made to interest in daily life, and this interest is
inseparable from the tendency of this-world orientation.
In traditional Japanese Buddhism, the Pure Land sects show a
conspicuous trend toward an other-world orientation. In particular, as
Buddhism came to be increasingly involved in conducting funerals and
memorial services, the tendency of Japanese Buddhism toward other-world
orientation was strengthened. On the other hand, interest in this world
continued to exist in Japanese Buddhism, which was derived from
esoteric Buddhism and the Tendai Hongaku (Original Enlightenment)
philosophy, and this tendency occupied a strong position in the Lotus
Sutra/Nichiren Buddhist tradition. One expression of this-world
orientation is interest in divine favor in this world. In the Lotus
Sutra, promises that people can become free from turmoil in this world
frequently appear. They include an emphasis on meritorious deeds and on
salvation from all kinds of sufferings (chapters 25, on the bodhisattva
Kannon, and 26, on dharani, or the mystic Buddhist formula). In
the Lotus Sutra, one is supposed to seek enlightenment and nirvana in
this world while interacting with others. A typical example is found in
chapter 20, on the bodhisattva Never Despise, which depicts a monk who
venerates all people he meets for their potential to become buddhas.
This-world orientation became quite strong in Nichiren Buddhism. By introducing the chanting of the daimoku,
practices as instructed in the Lotus Sutra, including remembering its
teachings, were simplified and made easier. At the same time, greater
importance was given to the ideas that divine favor could be realized
during one's lifetime and that buddhahood could be attained in this
world. The simplification of practice was based on the interpretation
of Chih-i's doctrine of the "three thousand realms in a single
thought." Here the foundation of the salvation theory was established.
Texts such as the Kanjin honzon sho (The object of worship in contemplation) by Nichiren were developed on the theory of this-world-oriented salvation.
It is easy to understand that the this-world orientation in the
Lotus Sutra/Nichiren tradition found sympathy among modern Japanese who
are interested in improving their destinies and in contributing to the
solution of common problems. New Religions in the Lotus Sutra/Nichiren
tradition have positively advocated the realization of divine favor and
meritorious deeds and have taught that each individual can be reborn
through these practices to live a new life in this world. They
encourage people to address common problems while positively
interacting with others so that they can live a fulfilled life.
Interrelationship among the Three Concepts
These three concepts are interrelated. The vision for integration based
on horizontal solidarity is related to the principle of self-reliance,
which is linked to this-world orientation, and this naturally has a
tendency to bring religious values closer to home. This-world
orientation is often connected with the tendency of people to share
matters of common interest, since it aims to address the problems in
their daily lives as religious problems that need to be fixed in order
to improve their lives.
The three concepts are deeply related to the bodhisattva practices.
When focusing on religious practices, the principle of self-reliance is
the most deeply related to bodhisattva practices. But the three are
also deeply related to the concept of integration through horizontal
solidarity and this-world orientation because they relate to people's
daily lives and bring about religious integration while people are
still involved in the problems in this world. An analysis of the
characteristics of modern religious movements focusing on the tradition
of Lotus Sutra/Nichiren Buddhism would reveal several notable aspects
of the bodhisattva practices.
Integration through Horizontal Solidarity in Lotus Sutra/Nichiren-Related New Religions
While being influenced by nationalism, by practices intended to
facilitate participation in society, by a criticism against
authoritarian hierarchic social relations, and by individualism and
egocentrism, New Religions presented a new integrated vision based on
horizontal solidarity and gained people's support. In the following
sections, the emphasis placed on matters of daily interest,
nationalism, and participation in society are examined.
Emphasis on Matters of Daily Interest and Talking about Personal Experiences
The representative movements of Lotus Sutra/Nichiren-school Buddhism
during the Meiji period (1868-1912) were Honmon Butsuryuko and
Kokuchukai. As both were established in the same period and both
followed the same Lotus Sutra/Nichiren-school Buddhism, they naturally
had much in common. When compared, however, they are found to present
distinct differences. The leaders of both movements emerged from Lotus
Sutra/Nichiren-sect lay associations in the Tokugawa period. Honmon
Butsuryuko evolved as a mass movement, while Kokuchukai developed as an
ideological movement, mainly among intellectuals. While Honmon
Butsuryuko emphasized the pursuit of divine favor in this world with a
strong tendency toward privatism focusing its attention on matters of
daily interest, Kokuchukai (Association of the State Pillar), as its
name suggests, focused on the integration of the nation and the
development of the religious sect (Nichiren organizations) as its major
concerns, with little interest in problems of people's daily lives.
Kokuchukai, which became independent but maintained both partner and
rival relationships with the Nichiren sect, has never developed into a
mass-movement religious organization. Therefore, if Kokuchukai can be
called a New Religion, it should be placed outside the mainstream on
the whole New Religion map.
The New Religions that were established later have more points in
common with Honmon Butsuryuko. After the late Taisho period (1912-26),
people-centered organizations became more concerned with practical
problems in daily life. The two most powerful organizations are
Reiyukai (and its offshoots) and Soka Gakkai. The concept of
integration through horizontal solidarity plays a great role in these
organizations. Along with the formation of a national society, the
awareness of individual independence, equality, and solidarity as
members of the nation was strengthened among the Japanese populace.
Against such a social background, Lotus Sutra/Nichiren-school New
Religions promoted their activities through nurturing the sense of
solidarity among members by sharing troubles and happiness in the daily
lives of the followers. Most notable were small-group activities and
the sharing of personal experience.
Small-group activities that had begun as the activity of such lay
associations as Hokkeko and Daimokuko in the Tokugawa period were
placed in the center of the religious activity of the lay-centered
Honmon Butsuryuko. Nissen Nagamatsu, its founder, apprehended that the
current state of the Buddhist community as led by priests, especially
the Nichiren sect, was suffocating Buddhist belief in its true sense
and oppressing solidarity among lay followers. He attempted to build a
network of solidarity based on associations of lay followers instead of
on temples led by priests. The horizontal network of organizations of
lay followers and religious practices conducted therein laid the
foundation for the later mass movements of the sect. Honmon Butsuryuko
played an important role in forming the concept of lay Buddhism.
Small-group activities by lay followers expanded explosively in and
after the 1920s in both Reiyukai (and its offshoots) and Soka Gakkai.
One of the driving forces of that development was an activity in which
people talked about personal experiences. Reiyukai encouraged its
members to talk about their experiences, teaching that they could
understand the core of religion only through experience, and saying
that anyone could take part in horizontal solidarity by sharing
experiences. A little later, Soka Gakkai also encouraged its members to
create value in their lives while building horizontal solidarity
through roundtable meeting activities. The outstanding characteristic
of Lotus Sutra/Nichiren-school New Religions is that they allow their
followers to maintain their consciousness as religious followers and
are committed to horizontal solidarity.
Nationalism as a Vision of Integration
As stated above, one characteristic of New Religions is emphasis on
people's daily lives and the followers' participation in activities
through talking about their experiences. There are aspects of
individualism that emphasize people's own experiences and the
realization of their happiness and that require individuals to make
efforts to realize their happiness. Interest in the pursuit of divine
favor in this world and in the solution of conflicts in everyday life
is prominent in Honmon Butsuryuko and other New Religions following
Lotus Sutra/Nichiren Buddhism. They are related to the principle of
self-reliance. Reiyukai and Soka Gakkai also have the vision of
ultimately integrating society by working toward the realization of the
ideal world. In this respect, these New Religions are inheriting the
horizon explored by Kokuchukai.
The nationalistic vision of integration in Lotus Sutra/
Nichiren-school New Religions stems from Nichiren, who advocated the
salvation of the nation through the Lotus Sutra at the critical time
just before the Mongolian attack on Japan. With the conviction that the
unification of religions was required to overcome the crisis, Nichiren
put forward a proposal for national integration and rescuing the state
by the Lotus Sutra. Behind his belief was the sense of crisis stemming
from the feeling of pessimism that arose from the theory of the Latter
Day of the Law. There was, on the other hand, a future-oriented
utopia-like sense of time (Sueki, 2000). After the Meiji period, this
tradition was reactivated by movements such as Kokuchukai, led by
Chigaku Tanaka, and as a result, Lotus Sutra/Nichiren Buddhism became
one of the main bearers of religious nationalism in modern Japan.
Tanaka considered the "ordination platform of Honmon" as the "national
ordination platform" and put forth his vision to save the state and
build an ideal society by establishing it firmly. A little later,
Toshizo Nishida founded Bussho Gonenkai (1906-18) and taught that
saving the state and realizing the mission of the state should be
achieved through conducting ancestor worship based on the Lotus Sutra.
The prewar movement of Soka Gakkai had an underlying vision of the
millennium and strove to create an ideal world through the construction
of the national ordination platform. However, this vision was not
publicly announced because of the prewar social situation. This was
also true with Reiyukai, which has inherited the philosophy of Nishida
almost entirely. In considering the characteristics of New Religions,
it is important to note that the two movements had the same vision
before the end of World War II-that the relief of the state can be
achieved through the integration of horizontal solidarity under Lotus
Sutra/Nichiren Buddhism. After the 1930s, the whole nation was
mobilized under State Shinto, and the vision of the salvation of people
and the world by the emperor-centered state prevailed. During this
period, Lotus Sutra/Nichiren-school religious movements were
accumulating the philosophical resources that would provide the vision
of integration based on horizontal solidarity, which was different from
the vision of State Shinto.
After World War II, Lotus Sutra/Nichiren-school New Religions made
great advances, and in the process, the nationalistic integration
vision played an important role. In both Soka Gakkai and Reiyukai, the
idea that true Buddhism would prevail and that the state would be saved
through their movements played a large role. But needless to say, the
ideological climate after the war was greatly changed. Soka Gakkai has
poured much energy into political activities, and because of this, its
vision of integration through the state as a medium has been maintained
and given a concrete image. Even so, the objective of the organization
has tended to be the expansion of its political forces in actual
politics, and its vision to save human beings has lost ground. In
postwar New Religions, the vision of integration based on horizontal
solidarity was sought for dimensions that cannot be achieved by
salvation through the state. That is a vision of integration through
society.
Integration through Society
As members of society, religious organizations adapt themselves to
society or oppose it while being pressured and influenced by it; at the
same time, they gain opportunities to be positively involved in solving
various problems in society in their own ways. Typical examples are
conducting welfare and charity activities, contributing to education
and medical care, and peace movements. In the 1900s, Christian
organizations presented abundant activity models in these fields.
Traditional Buddhist organizations also began to carry out various
social activities. Then New Religions such as Tenri-kyo began social
activities on a small scale. The Lotus Sutra/ Nichiren-school movement
widely conducted relief activities at times of war and natural
disasters as well as long-term charitable social activities. However,
these activities were not part of the main field of activities of the
religious organizations.
Already in the second decade of the 1900s, there was a budding
movement among New Religions under the Lotus Sutra/Nichiren school that
attempted to pursue horizontal solidarity in society, rather than
developing solidarity among their own groups and people around
themselves or aiming to achieve their vision of the millennium using
the state as an intermediary step. A remarkable example was Bukkyo
Kanka Kyusaikai (Buddhist Influence and Relief Association), which
would later develop into organizations such as Hoonji and Daijokyo.
Tatsuko Sugiyama, its founder, considered support activities for needy
people and suffering people outside the community of those who shared
the same faith to be an essential part of religious activities. She was
earnestly engaged in relief activities ranging from attempting to heal
lepers through faith healing and supporting hospital management to
managing social welfare institutions for disabled children and others
and establishing educational institutions for social welfare workers.
The activities of Bukkyo Kanka Kyusaikai can be seen as responses to
the social problems that became apparent in large cities after the
1890s and more seriously in the early 1900s. In these decades, gaps
between landowners and tenant farmers and between capitalists and
laborers expanded, slums in cities increased, girls endured wretched
working conditions in factories, and the miserable conditions of the
families of deceased and invalid soldiers became apparent. The
government gave greater attention to relief activities and at the same
time expected the private sector to provide social service activities
also. The government, however, was cautious about religious groups,
gaining greater numbers of followers and supporters by preaching divine
favors such as healing diseases, and the authorities sometimes
controlled the activities of religious groups. This suppression may be
a reason underlying Sugiyama's promotion of relief activities in
partnership with medical institutions. Sugiyama and her successors,
Hitoshi Murakami and Shugaku Suzuki, were eagerly engaged in
caregiving, as they considered their service to be a practical act of
bodhisattva practices through which they could train themselves as
bodhisattvas. The care activity of Bukkyo Kanka Kyusaikai was passed on
to Hoonji Temple, which Suzuki succeeded after World War II, and has
continued to date.
After World War II, large-scale welfare or environmental improvement
activities and peace movements were begun by many religious
organizations. The most notable in terms of scale is the peace movement
by Rissho Kosei-kai and Myochikai, which is inseparable from religious
cooperation activities. The antiwar and anti-A-bomb movements during
the Korean War and the Cold War between East and West in the 1950s led
to the rise of nationwide peace movements that developed to express the
nation's will to rebuild Japan as a peace-oriented state. New
Religions, in particular some of those in the Lotus Sutra/Nichiren
school, played a great role in developing a groundswell for the peace
movement by their religious cooperation in organizing movements.
Rissho Kosei-kai played a great role in the establishment of the
World Conference of Religions for Peace in 1970 and its development in
the following years. It launched the Brighter Society Movement and thus
involved local branch organizations in peace and environmental
activities. It was intended to expand the concept of bodhisattva
practice to people outside the organization through interacting with
nonmembers by participating in religious cooperation and community
environmental activities.
At the beginning of the twenty-first century, Myochikai, while
cooperating with the activities of the World Conference of Religions
for Peace, launched moral education for children as a part of its
international cooperation. Because of its exclusivist doctrine, Soka
Gakkai does not participate in cooperation activities with other
religious organizations. It chooses to expand its contact with society
not only through the activities of its associate political party (New
Komeito) but also through direct contact with the general public
through its own activities. Peace is also a great theme for Soka
Gakkai. It aims to contribute to world peace through the leader's
outgoing international activities, exhibitions, and publications. These
are typical contemporary examples of bringing about the vision of
integration through horizontal solidarity that the New Religions of the
Lotus Sutra/ Nichiren school have been pursuing.
Exclusivity and Toleration
In the Lotus
Sutra/Nichiren Buddhist tradition, there is a tendency for subsect
organizations to be divided into exclusive and intolerant groups
regarding the diversity of thought and faith. Nichiren accused Buddhist
sects in his day of reviling the teachings of the Buddha by not
following the Lotus Sutra, which strongly urges people to have faith in
that sutra rather than other sutras. It may be understood that the
Lotus Sutra itself is exclusivist in nature. But although it places
some teachings of Shakyamuni Buddha that have been conveyed in other
forms at lower positions, this does not mean that the value of these
teachings is totally denied but that they are recognized as being
"skillful means." As such, both exclusive and tolerant positions have
come to coexist in the integration vision presented by New Religions in
the Lotus Sutra/Nichiren school. The exclusivist position is
represented by Honmon Butsuryuko and Soka Gakkai, and the tolerant
position by Hoonji, Rissho Kosei-kai, and Myochikai.
Both positions can be seen as responses to the disunion in ideology
and values that became apparent in the process of modernization. One
tendency looks at the vision of integration through horizontal
solidarity as a means to develop solidarity among followers in the
organization and to exclude those who do not positively enter the
circle of solidarity. The other tendency is to consider that people
outside the followers' groups should also be incorporated into the
circle of their solidarity. The latter position is deeply connected
with "cooperation" for the state or, in other words, the "cooperation"
demanded by the state that was prevalent before 1945. Religious
cooperation in Japan began with a tripartite meeting in 1912, when
representatives from Shinto, Buddhism, and Christianity met together at
the same table and began a dialogue. This was initiated by the
government and by scholars who were cooperating with the government.
Later, religious cooperation for peace and religious cooperation in
support of war efforts by the state were both promoted. There were also
cases of voluntary religious cooperation, but the great majority of the
cases were led by the state and were carried out with the intention to
achieve goals set by the state. The prewar experience provided the base
for religious cooperation after World War II.
After World War II, voluntary cooperation among religious
organizations was promoted. Reflecting the prewar suppression of
religious activities by the government, religious cooperation was
overshadowed by a fear of state control and nationalism. In particular,
this fear was strongly shared among the affiliates of Shinshuren
(Federation of New Religious Organizations of Japan), which was founded
in 1951. An important point is that international religious cooperation
was promoted through the activities of the World Conference of
Religions for Peace and other groups. New Religions became aware of
international society and have begun to pour great amounts of energy
into interreligious cooperation activities and peace movements.
Syncretized Shinto-oriented New Religions such as Oomoto and Konkokyo
have made great contributions in this field, as well as Lotus
Sutra/Nichiren-school organizations. It was a notable development in
postwar days that their integrated vision of horizontal solidarity had
evolved into expanding voluntary religious cooperation and activities
in international society.
Uniqueness of the Concept of Integration Based on Horizontal Solidarity in Modern Japan
New Religions have carried on and further developed the concept of
integration based on horizontal solidarity in the Lotus Sutra/Nichiren
Buddhist concept of bodhisattva practice, which is an important element
in the Lotus Sutra that was developed through Nichiren Buddhism and
that bears the distinctive characteristics of Japanese Buddhism and of
the modern age.
Characteristics of Japanese Buddhism Seen in the Integration Concept of New Religions in the Lotus Sutra/Nichiren Tradition
Buddhist organizations in other countries may place significance on
faith and practice by lay followers, but one unique characteristic of
Japanese Buddhism is that it places such great significance on the
faith and practice of laypeople. The term lay orientation implies all
the characteristics of the concept of integration through horizontal
solidarity, the principle of self-reliance, and this-world orientation.
The fact that the term already existed in Japan before modern times may
suggest that it is a notable characteristic of Japanese Buddhism. The
formation of lay orientation may have been related to the process of
positive efforts to spread Japanese Buddhism among people while being
influenced by the Lotus Sutra, Pure Land teachings, and esoteric
Buddhism, and while promoting its spread through syncretization with
Shinto.
The move to enhance the involvement of laypeople by removing the
distinction between them and monks appears in historic documents from
the Nara period (710-94), together with the names of Gyoki and En no
Ozunu. The Pure Land and the Shugendo (mountain asceticism) traditions
promoted their nonorthodox ways of training and practices for laypeople
in respective directions, resulting in the relativization of the
authority of those who had taken the tonsure. Nonpriests and nonlay
leaders were developed in organized ways in Shugendo and in the Pure
Land sects to meet the people's quest for salvation. Moreover, recluse
monks in black clothing in the Kamakura period (1185- 1333) and
Buddhist groups formed by recluse monks became widespread in other
forms. It should be remembered that the wide prevalence of lay Buddhist
followers has supported the development of Lotus Sutra/Nichiren
Buddhism in Japan.
Nichiren himself did not encourage lay orientation. However, the
trend to place emphasis on laypeople developed in the Nichiren
tradition in the form of lay associations eventually called Hokke-ko
and other names. The most active lay associations were the Happon
subsect of the Honnoji Temple school of the Nichiryu line, and
Fujimon-ryu of the Taisekiji Temple school of the Nikko line in Edo
(Tokyo) and Kyoto toward the end of the Tokugawa period. Honmon
Butsuryuko and Soka Gakkai both reflect this lay tradition. In the
meanwhile, during the Tokugawa period, the tradition of the Nichiren
sect was united with shamanism, and follower groups were formed around
ascetics who responded to people's needs. Nyoraikyo, the earliest New
Religion, was established by a woman in Atsuta in Owari Province
(present-day Aichi Prefecture), a former servant in a warrior's house,
who was strongly influenced by an ascetic of Nichiren Buddhism. The
foundation of Reiyukai's movement was laid by Chise Wakatsuki, a female
ascetic in Nichiren Buddhism, in cooperation with Kakutaro Kubo.
These lay associations of the two lines of Nichiren Buddhism have
contrasting natures, in that one inherits its exclusive nature while
the other inherits its tolerant nature and syncretism with Shinto. Even
before the Meiji Restoration (1868), there were two lines of religious
organizations aiming for horizontal solidarity by involving laypeople
as participants, advocating both exclusivity on the one hand and
tolerance on the other.
The development of the tradition of bodhisattva practice in the
Lotus Sutra in the direction of nationalism is deeply related to the
tradition emphasized in Japanese Buddhism of keeping the nation
tranquil by reciting Buddhist prayers and conducting Buddhist
ceremonies. Historically, this began with Prince Shotoku (574-622), who
placed a premium on the Lotus Sutra; he was succeeded by Saicho and
Nichiren, who emphasized the concept of protecting and saving the
nation through the Lotus Sutra. Nichiren, in particular, warned Japan
of the danger of Mongolian invasion and taught that the nation could be
saved by the Lotus Sutra and through constructing an ideal Buddhist
state. He redirected the concept of integration based on horizontal
solidarity toward integration under the state. The fact that the
Nichiren Buddhist tradition was so influential in Japan in the modern
age of nationalism will not be understood without taking into account
its concern for protecting and saving the nation.
As described above, the spread of lay-centered religious
organizations and the strong interest in national integration in
Nichiren Buddhism laid the foundation for the development of New
Religions in the Lotus Sutra/Nichiren tradition. The concept of
integration through horizontal solidarity upheld by those New Religions
has evolved on the basis of the lay-centered Buddhist tradition, which
is also concerned with national integration. Both the Lotus Sutra and
Nichiren Buddhism put forward the integration concept based on
horizontal solidarity. This can be understood as a part of the
characteristics of bodhisattva practice, one of the central concepts of
the Lotus Sutra.
Modernity of the Integration Concept of New Religions
Thanks to the advancement of printing techniques and school education,
the formation and spread of a national consciousness reflecting a
democratic political ideology became prevalent not only in Japan but
also in various countries from the beginning of the nineteenth century
onward. The vision of integration through horizontal solidarity and the
vision contained in various New Religions have evolved in many
entangled ways. A religious tradition emphasizing the subjectivity or
self-reliance of the people may have found it easier to keep pace with
democratic nation-states.
Among the New Religions of the Lotus Sutra/Nichiren school, very few
organizations have developed away from the trend of nationalism. Among
them, those that were founded and have developed rapidly between the
1920s and the 1960s have the strongest inclination toward nationalism.
Typical are Reiyukai and Soka Gakkai. In these organizations,
nationalism was associated with their vision of the millennium and was
developed while competing with State Shintoist nationalism. The
integrated vision of Lotus Sutra/ Nichiren Buddhism was based strongly
on horizontal solidarity and was favorably accepted by people as a
guiding principle to use in overcoming any crises confronting the
nation. It is no wonder, therefore, that the integrated vision of New
Religions contains abundant elements of nationalism.
In modern times, people have become increasingly aware not only of
the existence of various religions and people within each country but
also of the need for coexistence of all countries and cultures in the
world. Religious organizations are required to show an awareness of
being members of global society and also to display a religious spirit
while coping with social needs. It is against the social background of
modern times that the perception of religious diversity and the
promotion of international cooperation for peace have come to occupy
important positions in the New Religions of the Lotus Sutra/Nichiren
tradition. These features were observed earlier in Bukkyo Kanka
Kyusaikai. In postwar days, the concept of integration in diversity has
developed in Rissho Kosei-kai, Myochikai, Soka Gakkai, and other
religious organizations.
Finally, it should be noted that the integrated vision of horizontal
solidarity of New Religions has kept pace with modern egalitarianism
and progressive thought. One feature of Lotus Sutra/Nichiren-school New
Religions is that they evaluate the development of modern times
positively. Integration based on horizontal solidarity greatly affects
their evaluation. They believe that people can attain direct access to
the truth taught in the Lotus Sutra and involve themselves in the
practice of genuine Buddhism because of the advancements made in modern
times. On the other hand, the pessimistic view based on the concept of
the Latter Day of the Law is also emphasized, warning that righteous
Buddhism is not practiced in current times and that a crisis is
growing. Contradictory as these two ideas may appear, they can be seen
to be supporting each other in a state of delicate balance. While
celebrating advances in the human spirit together with technological
progress, these organizations also see the human tendency to become
violent and to ignore the truth-against which genuine Buddhism should
take a stand.
New Religions in the Lotus Sutra/Nichiren school can be understood
as examples of a modern embodiment of Mahayana Buddhism, more
specifically, its concept of bodhisattva practices. However, in order
to fully understand this, its entire historical development must be
considered from ancient times, when Mahayana Buddhism and the Lotus
Sutra were conveyed to Japan through China, accepted in the Japanese
style, and crystallized as Lotus Sutra/Nichiren Buddhism through the
great efforts of such intermediaries as Saicho and Nichiren.